Supreme Court Denies 89-Year-Old Man’s 27-Year Divorce Battle

Supreme Court Denies 89-Year-Old Man's 27-Year Divorce Battle

VoM News Desk | October 13, 2023 | 04:04 PM IST | Breaking News, Courts & Law | Follow on Google News

Supreme Court Denies 89-Year-Old Man’s 27-Year Divorce Battle

Supreme Court Denies 89-Year-Old Man’s 27-Year Divorce Battle

In a case that highlights the complexities of divorce in India, the Supreme Court has refused an 89-year-old man’s request to end his marriage of over six decades. The astonishing legal battle had spanned 27 long years since he initially sought to dissolve the marriage, revealing the enduring taboo surrounding divorce in much of the country.

The man, Nirmal Singh Panesar, had married in 1963, and he claimed that his relationship with his wife had become irretrievably broken by 1984. However, India’s divorce system is laden with challenges and legal hurdles, and approval from the courts is rarely granted unless there is substantial evidence of cruelty, violence, or unreasonable financial demands.

Nirmal Singh first filed for divorce in 1996, citing cruelty and desertion as grounds for the dissolution. Although a district court granted his request in 2000, this decision was later overturned following an appeal by his wife, Paramjit Kaur Panesar, who is now 82.

This case endured further legal battles, eventually reaching the Supreme Court, which acknowledged that the marriage was “beyond salvation” but still denied the divorce petition. The court’s judgment, published on Thursday, stated that the institution of marriage was viewed as sacred and invaluable in Indian society. Granting the dissolution, it argued, would be an “injustice” to Paramjit, who had expressed her desire to avoid the “stigma” of being labeled a divorcee. She also emphasized her willingness to care for her husband in his old age, underscoring the importance of their “sacred relationship.”

Chronic Backlogs and Lengthy Legal Battles

This case exemplifies the chronic backlogs in India’s criminal justice system, where some legal disputes can take decades to reach a resolution. Last year, the government reported that around 43.2 million cases were pending before courts across the country. The system’s inefficiencies have exacerbated the emotional and financial toll on litigants and perpetuated the difficulty of obtaining a divorce.

The judgment of this particular case reflects the deep-rooted cultural significance of marriage in India and the social pressure to uphold the institution. Divorce remains an uncommon occurrence, further highlighting the challenges individuals face when seeking to end unhappy marriages.

VoM News Desk

VoM News is an online web portal in jammu Kashmir offers regional, National & global news.